Bad Podcast Pitches

Bad Podcast Pitches



There are tons of bad pitches out there. Listen to the bad ones to recognize them when you receive them and avoid sending them yourself.

Support the Show

15 December 2025

guests for Mike (And a Podcast Promotion Update) - E10

Rewind 10 seconds
1X
Skip 30 seconds ahead
0:00/0:00

Share on social media:


This pitch comes to me from my friend Mike Wilkerson of 2GuysTalking.com and PodcastGauntlet.com (and many other places online). Listen as we examine this rather questionable pitch.

Oh... and a quick update on whether the incredible increase from our friendly neighborhood podcast promoter has continued.

Subscribe & Follow
Fountain | TrueFans | Podcast Guru | Other apps 


My friend and cohost, Mike Wilkerson, received a vague email promising “8–15 qualified guests every four weeks” using a “pay for performance” model, without advertising. While I appreciate short and sweet, brevity isn't enough. This email was missing some critical information to know whether it was worth pursuing.

I share my thoughts on what's missing, what you might want to do first if you receive a pitch like this and want to know more, and one thing that should be a non-negotiable.

If you're sending pitches, you will also find some valuable information about what you should do before sending a pitch.

Support & Connect
Listen Live in the Pitch Room
The Pitch Room (Live) | Chat

Create Your Own Show:
How I create this show, including tools, software, and the gear I use.

https://badpodcastpitches.com/tools/ 

Chapters:

(00:00) Opening and premise: dissecting a short pitch

(00:29) Context: Mike Wilkerson and the email setup

(00:50) Reading the pitch: promises and ambiguities

(01:33) Interpreting the offer and potential models

(02:42) Marketplace vs. middleman and dual-sided payment concerns

(03:42) Advice: define terms like pay for performance and qualified guest

(04:56) Audience fit matters: what qualifies a guest?

(06:01) Do your homework: tailoring pitches to the show

(06:29) Follow-up on prior promotion: results and takeaways

(07:44) Call for submissions and closing notices


Share on social media:


Listen in your favorite app:



More options

Here are shows you might like

See show recommendations
Podcast Editors Mastermind
Steve Stewart, Mark Deal
The Podcast Gauntlet - Throw Down, Discuss, Rise & Shine in Podcasting
Mike Wilkerson & Bryan Entzminger
Podcasting 2.0
Podcast Index LLC
The Future of Podcasting
Dave Jackson & Daniel J. Lewis
Podnews Weekly Review
James Cridland and Sam Sethi
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Podnews Daily - podcast industry news
Podnews LLC

Copyright Bryan Entzminger
SHOW SPONSORS Top Tier Audio
Top Tier Audio

Top Tier Audio is my podcast production company. I specialize in high quality podcast post-production for professionals.

https://toptieraudio.com